SIGNS
Published on the first of each month
September 30, 2024
SIGNS
July 1, 2024
LIGHTNING-FAST REJECTIONS
I am crushed whenever I receive a rapid rejection. I'm talking about querying a manuscript and getting a rejection in a few hours after submitting it.
This kind of a response feels personal even though I know it isn't. It makes my goal of finding representation that more urgent.
A speedy rejection gets me wondering: How did the agent know so quickly that my submission was not for her? Could she tell by looking at the title or word count? Did she dislike the voice of the story? The theme? The message? What made her decide so fast?
Is it a magic yes-no radar some agents possess? It must be because I've received a one-day reply from an agent who LIKED one of my manuscripts and wanted to read more of my work.
The positive takeaway of a quick rejection lets me know right away this agent didn't connect with my work and I can go down my list and submit it to other agents. Even still, it frustrates me. I spend hours revising my manuscripts and the query letters and filling out the Query Manager forms. So, receiving a rejection so quickly makes me feel like my writing and querying is a waste of time.
However, I am grateful for the response. In most cases, writers may have to wait up to 6 weeks or longer to hear back from an agent. Sometimes, and quite often, an author will never hear back. These days, no response means no thank you. In fact, many agents state on their guidelines that after X number of weeks the manuscript is no longer under consideration.
So after the sting of a lightning-fast rejection wears off, I bounce back ready to submit again. I'll peruse another agent's wish list to see if my manuscript might be something she's liked to see in her inbox.
Easier said than done.
Agents have to fall head over heels in love with the story and be able to sell it a publisher. They have very specific openings on their lists for perfect fits. Writers can get a sense of an agent's goals by studying wish lists and guidelines, but these merely hint at what the agent needs. Writers don't know exactly what an agent's list looks like and how an agent wants to fill her list.
The best thing a writer can do is try to make a very good match. Take for instance the time I decided to send a manuscript that seemed to meet the needs of the agent. My submission also included back matter for teachers (a good marketing approach) and sent it to an agent who had been an educator.
And the reply in less than two hours: "Thank you for your submission. Unfortunately, my picture book list
is quite full so I have to be extra picky and this one just isn't a fit. Please
know that this has nothing to do with your concept or the quality of your
writing - I love what you've done here and wish I could represent every good
book to come across my desk. Don't let
this discourage you. Another agent may feel differently and you deserve to have
an agent as passionate about your work as you are."
Super nice rejection. Personalized. But, thought I had made a very good match. Evidently not good enough.
Negativity started to get me down. At this low point I searched the internet to find how to deal with rejection and found I found Powerful Positive Thinking, a website where anyone can send a wish into the universe. As silly as it may seem to some, I like having the opportunity to visualize success. It feels empowering. Nearly every day I make a wish. But that's not all. The creators of Powerful Positive Thinking insist we take action. So, after making a wish, I work on my queries and my agent list. I polish my manuscripts. And I try not to compare myself to others.
I believe in the quality of my writing. So does my husband and my critique partners. But when life delivers a knock, I begin to doubt my abilities. Then I remember a rejection (no matter how fast it's received) is the universe's way of saying keep going. Keep learning. Keep envisioning success. Sure, it would be easier to give up writing to avoid the pain of rejection. But then, I'd never know. The next submission could be the perfect fit.
À la prochaine!
"Giving up is the only sure way to fail." Gena Showalter, author
December 1, 2023
It bugs me when people don't reply, can't say no, can't admit they're not interested.
April 1, 2023
Photo: Gabrielle Henderson |
LETTING GO OF REGRET
I don't always make good decisions. And as a result, I end up having regret.
To illustrate, last month I entered one of my manuscripts in a pitch party. Minutes after submitting it, I knew I screwed up. The text could have been stronger and it did not reflect my best work.
I sulked over the manuscript for days because this submission opportunity only happens once a year. Talk about feeling down. And stupid. A chance to have a select group of picture book agents request my work—gone.
When I looked back at this misfortunate circumstance, it became apparent to me that a lingering migraine had altered my reasoning. Being foggy-brained is an effect of having a migraine. But since I was pain-free, I hadn't realized that making good decisions was impaired. If I had been thinking clearly, there would have been no way I would've submitted this version. My migraine brain deceived me into thinking the manuscript was in good shape. And I made a bad choice.
Now, it's water under the bridge (or the toothpaste is outta of the tube, as my husband would say) and now I know (most likely) that a silent migraine served me a heaping helping of regret.
Feeling miserable, I turned to the internet to find articles on remorse and regret. I found a helpful post written by Gila Gam titled Reframing Regret: from Hindsight to Insight
Since I can't do this piece justice by rephrasing, I quote Gila:
"Life is made up of a series of changes, choices, and consequences. The choices you make today will make sense in retrospect with time and reflection. The road is windy and slippery. Embrace the wobble. Keep walking and trust you will figure out your own way. So, turn the insights into foresight."
Turn insights into foresight. That's perfect, isn't it?
For me, that would mean paying closer attention to the effects of a migraine: recognizing mental clarity can be lacking after an attack and then refraining from making important decisions until the headache symptoms have subsided. But even if I'm aware, there are other ways to f*ck-up a submission: typos in a manuscript, misunderstanding the submission guidelines, or misspelling an agent's name. So, to lessen regret, I try to turn the negative feelings into positive feelings by visualizing mistakes as stepping stones that will lead me closer to my goals.
This wonderful submission opportunity seemed to be the chance of a lifetime and it hurts that I messed up. But there's always next year. Until then, I will keep going. I will remember this situation for a long time, but without regret. It happened for many reasons: To learn and to improve. To understand my limitations. To revel in my tenacity. I will keep moving forward along those stepping stones. And if things backfire or don't go as smoothly as hoped, I will reflect. I forge on to make things better next time.
À la prochaine!
November 1, 2019
Photo: Gus Ruballo |
Surprisingly audacious reflections of a humble writer
A HUGE MISTAKEMany years ago when I was an aspiring writer, I made a mistake. A huge mistake. A costly mistake. But first, the backstory:
Ever since I was a teen, I wanted to write, but my career path took a different direction and I became a medical technologist. After graduating, I landed a good-paying job at the University of Kentucky Medical Center. However, as the years rolled on, the work environment grew stressful due to downsizing and poor management. Luckily, I was able to retire early.
At that time, I decided to take a writing class. My desire to write for kids had been simmering for quite some time as my husband read picture books to our young daughter. But it wasn't because of the delightful stories that drew me to writing. It was because of an unimaginative story he had read to her. I wondered how it ever got published. This sad little picture book pushed me to learn how to write for children. If something like this could be published, then surely I could write a picture book.
So, I enrolled in a class at the Carnegie Center for Literacy and Learning to discover how to write for kids. Towards the end of the course, all of the participants had written a picture book manuscript. Many of us hoped to get our work published. As it was, I had already begun sending out my manuscript to publishing houses...and it was getting rejected time after time.
On the last day of class, our instructor had a surprise for us. She invited a literary agent to speak to us. This was an amazing opportunity. The agent gave a brief lecture and then after a question and answer period, she handed out her business cards.
I wasted no time in contacting her and we arranged a time to get together. A few weeks later, I drove about 30 miles from Lexington to her farmhouse in central Kentucky. She served a light snack and then she discussed which agents she would contact and how she would present my book to them. I was so ready to work with an agent and this was the ticket to getting published. The timing seemed perfect to me.
But I was so naive. This situation was all wrong because:
Just pretend this was me, shelling out beaucoup de money to an agent. Photo: Sharon McCutcheon |
2. I paid her a fee—a whopping three hundred dollars to be represented. Ouch! I took for it for granted that this was the way agents worked and that writers paid them upfront.
Since then, I've grown as a writer. I took more classes, read books on the craft of writing for kids, and joined the Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators (SCBWI). And through SCBWI, I learned about the Association of Authors' Representatives. Founded in 1991, the Association of Authors' Representatives (AAR) is a nonprofit membership organization which has more than 400 professional literary and dramatic agents as members. Members must meet the AAR's minimum experience requirements and agree to adhere to its bylaws and the canon of ethics. Agents do not charge a writer a flat fee for signing a contract—they are paid for their work through the commission they make when they sell a book.
Looking back to the time when I began seriously writing for children, I see a starry-eyed dreamer who made lots of mistakes because she desperately wanted to publish beautifully illustrated books for kids. I'm still this starry-eyed dreamer, but a tad smarter. Now, I do things differently. Before querying an agent, I revise my manuscript countless times and I have a second reader critique the piece. In addition, I shop around for reputable agents that represent picture books.
I have no regrets about the blunders I made in regards to writing. And no doubt I'll make more mistakes. But that's not necessarily a bad thing. Mistakes can be great teachers. We must recognize that as painful they may be, mistakes are part of any journey, part of anything we wish to excel at, and part of anything we wish achieve. Mistakes have the power to turn us into something even better than we were before.
"The only real mistake is the one from which we learn nothing." Henry Ford
Comments:
Great article! But shame on your instructor for not checking out the agent she invited to class.
Why wouldn't a student trust someone who their teacher had invited? Harold U.
December 1, 2018
Surprisingly audacious reflections of a humble writer
VENTING
I'm a venter. I am vocal about things that bother me. Just mention submitting and you'll get me going. Submitting to agents and publishers is frustrating.
It wasn't always like this.
Twenty years ago, a writer would simply send a submission in a 13 x 9" envelope with a cover letter and SASE (self-addressed stamped envelope) to an agent or an editor. Within about three months they'd receive a response in the mail. Writers would get a definite yes or a no about their manuscripts.
Now days writers submit electronically, and most publishers respond only IF they are interested.
Professional writers put thought, care, and time into every submission. And, we want to hear back. Instead, we wait three months wondering if our submission has even been received. We wait three months wondering if our submission has been read. We wait three months wondering if someone likes our work. We wait three months and hear nothing at all.
Whenever I used to discuss submitting with my mother-in-law, she would answer with an expression that rhythmically and rhetorically rolled off her tongue, "What are you doing to do?" Which meant: there's nothing you can do.
But that was not me. There was something I could do. I could vent about it.
Given the submission situation, I have found that I'm not alone. Other writers feel the same way. They're not happy about the way submitting has changed. They vent, too. And with all of this venting, you may wonder if it is healthy. So, I did a little investigating, but I found that the subject of venting is complicated and thorny.
Brad Bushman, professor of communication and psychology at Ohio State University and the lead author of the 2002 venting study says, “When people vent their anger, they want to hit, scream or shout, and it feels good to do that, and so they think, Oh, it feels good it must work,” says Bushman. “But it also feels good to take street drugs and eat donuts. But just because something feels good doesn’t mean it’s healthy.”
David M Reiss, M.D., a San Diego-based psychiatrist weighs in. He states, “There’s certainly an advantage to acknowledging your emotions and being able to express them.” Reiss believes there's a right way to vent. The key is finding the right person. “It has to be someone who is not just going to join you in the anger but is also going to help you to come to terms with it and help you calm down,” he says.
According to Psychology Today, there are positive and negative features to venting. While venting can increase level of distress and antagonize others, it can discharge negative emotion and can help you feel better. Dr. Leon F Sheltzer, Ph.D., an anger management specialist says, "Generally, it’s better to let things out than hold them in. And doing so feels almost akin to problem-solving—in the moment, at least. Venting your frustrations alleviates tension and stress."
For me, venting allows me to express my frustration and to let of negative energy. Regardless of what some experts say, I think it's healthy to let off steam. I'm all for venting.
Especially when I don't hear back from an agent about a manuscript that I love.
SO, COME ON NOW.
I'VE SENT YOU A PROFESSIONAL QUERY.
ALL I ASK IS FOR A LITTLE COURTESY.
DO YOU LIKE THE MANUSCRIPT OR NOT?
COMPOSE A ONE SENTENCE RESPONSE.
TELL ME FOR CRYING OUT LOUD.
LET ME KNOW.
IS IT YES OR IS IT NO?
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, HOW HARD CAN IT BE?
SEND
A
DAMN
EMAIL.
I'm glad to get that off my chest.
À la prochaine!
July 12, 2018
Surprisingly audacious reflections of a humble writer
THE DEADLIEST CRAB
That's my cue to join him to watch an episode of the Deadliest Catch. Or as I like to call it, the Deadliest Crab.
Deadliest Catch follows six sea captains and their crew as they hunt for elusive Alaskan crab. Viewers can always count on drama. Sea captains battle:
- arctic storms with hurricane-force winds and 40 foot waves
- ice floes
- snow blindness
- crew management
- accidents that cause serious injury or death
- fatigue
- health issues (back issues and conditions brought on by stress)
- equipment failure which may lead to fires, oil leaks, power outage, or loss of steering
On top of all that, the captain must find crab. That's tricky because radar doesn't detect crabs resting upon the bottom of the sea.
Crab fishing is one of the most dangerous jobs in the country. It seems like once a season, Deadliest Catch airs footage of the United States Coast Guard searching for crewmen of capsized vessels or retrieving injured fishermen from a deck—a feat in itself as swimmers lower a rescue basket from a helicopter through rough wind onto a rocking ship.
Sea captain Josh Harris says, "It's not a sport for the weak or the weak-minded."
From time to time, a little levity peppers the show with the crew pulling silly pranks like filling a fisherman's boots with water and then freezing them or moving a captain's boat (unbeknownst to him) to another dock.
however, (say like when a steel crane smashes a forehead) or gross (or when a wound is lanced or part of a finger is lost), I'll look away while my husband replays the scene to be sure he hadn't missed any gore.
Writing for children is demanding (ask any children's author) but it's not usually deadly. With writing, you may face rejection, but you don't run the risk of getting bloody and gory...
and you never have to be on the lookout for crab farts.
CWW is published twice a month.
À la prochaine!
May 30, 2018
LEARNING WITH THE MANUSCRIPT ACADEMY
My new manuscript was sh*t. (My husband tried to warn me the piece needed more work).
Thinking it was good enough to submit, I had a 10-minute conversation with a literary agent, where I heard for a second time the story needed help.
This short phone call with a member of the Manuscript Academy saved me from submitting a poorly developed manuscript. Without having this conversation, I would have submitted my work to agents and gotten rejections (and been in the dark about why it was rejected).
I stumbled across this amazing online conference when I searched for agents. I read that for a low price, you could have a consultation with an agent to discuss a manuscript and a query letter.
I'm glad I did.
The Manuscript Academy is a unique online instruction can be enjoyed from the comfort of your home. All you need is a computer, a tablet, or even your smartphone to log in and you will receive advice and instruction from some of the best minds in the literary community.
Here is what is available:
- Access to exclusive recorded classes and panels, designed to educate you about need-to-know topics such as how to submit your work, what agents and editors are looking for, how to craft amazing novels and books, the business of writing and promotion, and much more. You will have access to many high-quality recorded video presentations for 30+ full days—so you can pause, rewind, and notes at your own convenience. See the full schedule of classes here.
- Opportunities to pitch agents and editors one-on-one online. Using just your computer, you can arrange one-on-one pitches with literary agents and publishing house editors who are actively seeking books and clients right now. (Pitches are optional. You can sign up for as many pitches as you like.)
- Critique opportunities for your work. If you want a professional critique of your work, then Manuscript Academy has opportunities for you. Our awesome faculty of agents, editors, and published authors offer detailed critiques of manuscript pages, query letters, synopses, and nonfiction book proposals. This is an amazing opportunity to get expert feedback on your work. Plus, Manuscript Academy members also gain access to our Academy Forum, which allows writers to connect with each other and form online writing critique groups.
- Live query and first page workshops and discussions (in groups of up to 10) on topics ranging from Publishing Law to How to Be A Trendsetter, Not Trendy. All of these are designed to be introvert friendly.
I clicked and moved my mouse frantically.
I got panicky. I wanted it to wake up, wake up, WAKE UP!
Luckily, I had jotted down my questions in advance so it was easy to continue. Halfway through our short conversation, the agent told me that the middle of my manuscript was weak. OMG, she suggested how to improve it!
$49 + 10 minutes = priceless knowledge
March 15, 2018
- How to get published: traditional presses versus
small presses
- How to write a picture book
- How to build an author platform
- How to give a school presentation
- How to get published in children's magazines
- How to develop a website or a blog
- How to query agents
- How to edit and proofread your work
Tips on presenting a workshop:
- Practice beforehand and time yourself
- Practice using inflections as you speak (avoid flat monotone
speaking)
- Look in a mirror as your practice
- Start the workshop with a brief intro which includes
your credentials
- Start the workshop by asking participant's experiences
and goals
- Begin with a personal anecdote
- Have visuals
- Bring water
- Get the participants involved by asking them questions
or their opinions
- Handout a list of resources the participants can use at
home
January 1, 2017
Resources for PB Writers
For those of you just beginning to write for children, check out these websites for tips on creating a picture book. For writers who have already written manuscripts, take a look at the resources before you submit to agents and editors.
HOW TO FORMAT YOUR PICTURE BOOK
Children's Writer's World wishes you, your family, and friends a happy New Year!
December 15, 2016
The Story that You Love
Over the summer I re-read a 1000-word picture book manuscript that I had written five years ago. I loved this story, but it was rejected time after time. I finally figured out that the piece was too long. So 500 words were cut. Afterward, the story was critiqued and revised and revised. A compelling query letter was crafted and the much shorter story was submitted. About a month later a handful of agents rejected it, but a publisher sent me an exciting note. She texted me that she liked the book! I screamed and jumped up and down like a maniac. She sent me a book contract, something I've been dreaming about and working toward for many, many years.
It's exciting to find someone who loves the book as much as I do. So based on my experience, I'd like to offer picture book writers some tips to help you get your work published.
1. Put the manuscript that you love on hold for a couple of months. In the meantime go online or to the library and read current picture books. Find one that speaks to your heart. Analyze it. Is it the voice, the theme, or the character that draw you to the story Use this book as inspiration or even as a model to guide you when it's time to revise your work.
3. Cut words. Today, publishers want stories under 500 words. You may feel that you will not be able to tell the whole story with fewer words, but lowering the word count will challenge you to tell a concise story.
4. Have a second reader have a look. Consider the suggestions and revise. Start writing the hook and the synopsis. Believe me, this will help you find areas in your picture book that may need editing.
October 1, 2016
Resources for Picture Book Writers
SCBWI - the Society for Children's Book Writers & Ilustrators, an organization that every children's writer and illustrator must join
LINDA ASHMAN author of The Nuts and Bolts Guide to Writing Picture Books
CHILDREN'S BOOK HUB - a paid subscription service with information about children's books, led by Emma Walton Hamilton
CHILDREN'S BOOK INSIDER - a paid subscription monthly newsletter with tips about publishers and agents, writing courses, and more
MEM FOX and her fabulous list of 20 DO'S AND DON'TS OF PICTURE BOOK WRITING. Learn tips on how to read a story out loud: READ ALOUD LESSON
THE PURPLE CRAYON - the website by Harold Underdown, author of The Complete Idiot's Guide to Publishing Children's Books. His site has resources and information, including an introductory article on the BASICS OF CHILDREN'S PUBLISHING
SUSAN UHLIG's link is full of resources from books to blog posts
July 1, 2016
Write
June 1, 2016
Submitting to Agents
1. No reply. Agents will only respond when they are interested. No word = no thank you.
2. The standard rejection form. It might read: Thank you for submitting but unfortunately it doesn't meet our needs at this time.
It is disappointing, but fairly common not to hear back from an agent. So if you haven't gotten a response in about three months, consider it a pass.
A good number of agents will usually send a rejection letter. Even though they've passed on your work, you will know that they received your submission and it had been considered.
Occasionally, a rejection letter may arrive personally addressed to you along with a little note. A note takes the sting out of the rejection. It could read: shape this piece, or this work has potential, or this project sounded interesting. You may even get advice, and if you do, consider revising your manuscript.
Though it is a pass on your project, a personalized rejection is an awesome thing to receive. An agent has made time to send you feedback. A personal message will remind you that others think your work has potential. It may offer hope and validation. It will boost your faith as a writer. And more, it will give you courage to keep on submitting.
March 15, 2016
To Be, or Not To Be Snappy
Other writers have met agents at conferences, and they feel confident enough to approach them with a snappy synopsis or bio. Again, there is no guarantee that a writer will snag an agent this way.